DIY Chew Toy Hacks Using Old Toys and Treats

Chew toys are more than just a way to keep your pets entertained-they help maintain dental health, alleviate stress, encourage natural behaviors, and can even strengthen the bond between pets and their humans. But toys wear down, and treats run out. Rather than discarding those worn favorites, there are smart, veterinarian-informed ways to give new life to old toys and turn leftover pieces into enriching, safe chew challenges. In this guide, we’ll walk you through multiple DIY chew toy hacks using recyclables, leftover treats, and a bit of creativity, all backed by science and focused on your pet’s wellbeing.

Why Chew Toys Matter

Before jumping into the hacks, it helps to understand the purpose of chew toys from a scientific and behavioral perspective. Dogs and cats chew instinctively-dogs chew to explore, relieve pain from teething, or release anxiety. Cats chew or bat items to simulate hunting. Providing your pet with mental stimulation is crucial, especially in indoor environments where natural stimulation is limited.

Veterinary behaviorists note that interactive chew toys can reduce unwanted behaviors, including excessive barking, destructive chewing, and separation anxiety. They also help satisfy neurological needs by triggering dopamine release through problem-solving. Additionally, according to veterinary dentistry studies, textured chew toys can help reduce plaque and tartar buildup when used regularly under supervision.

Hack #1: The “Tug-Ball” Revamp

Best For:

Dogs that enjoy tugging or have worn soft toys with some remaining structure.

Supplies:

• Frayed rope toy or an old plush toy with intact fabric knots
• Old tennis ball or chewable rubber treat dispenser
• Pet-safe thread or durable zip ties (no sharp edges)

Steps:

1. Stuff the soft toy’s hollow area with a small portion of a crunchy treat wrap (ensure it’s digestible and non-toxic).
2. Pierce the sides of the ball or wobbler and thread the knotted fabric or rope ends through the holes.
3. Secure the rope on both sides using pet-safe thread or zip ties, creating a tug-and-roll experience.

Why It Works:

The combination of rolling chase and tug resistance provides both physical and mental enrichment. It stimulates jaw movement, satisfies the natural desire to hunt prey-like objects, and is ergonomically suited for varied play styles.

Hack #2: Frozen Treat-Filled Chew Tubes

Best For:

Dogs and cats who like licking or mild chewing, especially in warm environments.

Supplies:

• Old hollow rubber toy (such as a Kong-style toy)
• Low-sodium bone broth or goat milk
• Crushed dental treats or twist of pet-safe herbs like parsley or mint
• Optional: shredded cooked chicken or pureed pumpkin

Instructions:

1. Mix bone broth or goat milk with crushed treats and optional ingredients.
2. Stuff the mixture into the toy, ensuring it’s tightly packed to prolong licking time.
3. Freeze for 4-6 hours until solid.

Why It Works:

Freezing changes the texture, increasing engagement and slowing down consumption. Temperature-stimulated enrichment has been linked to positive mood alterations and decreased cortisol levels. It also encourages healthy licking, which is soothing for many pets and helps prevent destructive alternatives.

Hack #3: Texture Swap with Modular Toy Parts

Best For:

Pets that get bored of toys quickly or are motivated by novelty.

Supplies:

• Two to three used chew toys with contrasting textures (e.g., soft fabric toy and a bumpy silicone bone)
• Non-toxic adhesive or strong knotting techniques

Instructions:

1. Cut off the ends or outer layers of each toy, focusing on keeping the unique textures intact.
2. Combine different sections-wrap the soft layer around a firmer core, or attach contrasting handles.
3. Secure tightly and perform a tug test to ensure safety before offering it to your pet.

Why It Works:

This method introduces novelty without introducing new objects, making it effective for pets that lose interest in familiar items. Animals are engaged by change. This multi-textured design also supports oral health via varied chewing surfaces while reducing consumer waste.

Hack #4: Wobbler Reinvention with Carrots and Crunch

Best For:

Pets who like problem-solving or require slow feeding alternatives.

Supplies:

• Old plastic or hard rubber treat-dispensing toy (like a wobble roller or puzzle feeder)
• Clean raw vegetable pieces (carrots, green beans)
• Sticky spread like plain natural peanut butter or sweet potato paste
• Crushed freeze-dried treats

Instructions:

1. Line the interior of the toy loosely with the paste.
2. Insert irregularly shaped vegetable chunks and crushed treats.
3. Tip the toy upright so pieces move freely within, allowing scent to guide your pet.

Why It Works:

The wobble function boosts vestibular and cognitive play. Using nutrient-dense low-calorie foods like carrots provides safe chewing while encouraging natural foraging behavior. Texture and taste variety mimics food-seeking in nature, supporting both physical and neurological stimulation.

Safety Guidelines

Always supervise your pets with any DIY toy, especially if parts are detachable or edible:

• Inspect After Use: Check for damage or fraying that could cause choking or digestive blockage.
• Know Your Pet’s Chewing Style: Moderate chewers may prefer softer textures, while heavy chewers require reinforced or rugged material.
• Use Only Pet-Safe Ingredients: Avoid xylitol, onions, garlic, raisins, and synthetic glues or fasteners.
• Hygiene: Sanitize toys regularly using warm water and pet-safe soap, or inspect if they are dishwasher-safe based on material.

Final Thought

Giving new life to old toys not only helps the environment and reduces waste, it provides deeper enrichment for your beloved pet. These simple, science-backed hacks are safe, enjoyable, and customizable. Start experimenting with what your pet responds to, and over time, you’ll sharpen their sensory experience, reduce anxiety, and enhance their physical and oral health-all with items you already have at home.